Mission Impossible: Positions determined by basic mapping-grade and recreation-grade GNSS receivers cannot emulate the actual spatial pattern of trees

TaeYoon Lee, Pete Bettinger, Krista Merry, Volkan Bektas, Chris Cieszewski

Abstract


Global navigation satellite systems (GNSS) can provide valuable spatial information for effectively mapping and navigating through forest conditions. The accuracy of GNSS receivers has been well-tested under many environmental conditions. Depending on the technology and conditions, different amounts of variation will occur in the determination of a horizontal position. However, studies involving the spatial pattern and distribution of tree locations observed by independent GNSS receivers generally have not considered the horizontal position error inherent in the spatial data. We conducted this study to investigate whether tree locations determined by GNSS receivers can adequately represent the real point pattern of trees in a forest. We tested three different GNSS receivers: one mapping-grade receiver and two recreation-grade receivers. We determined tree locations at cardinal points around the stems. We compared these observed tree locations to actual tree locations which were determined through precise field measurements. This study confirmed that the horizontal positional error of mapping grade receivers was significantly lower than those of recreation grade receivers, regardless of measurement method. However, the observed point pattern of trees from the GNSS observations by GNSS receivers failed to adequately represent the actual regular point pattern of the trees.


Keywords


Global navigation satellite system; complete spatial randomness; regular pattern; clustered pattern; root mean squared error; GPS receivers

Full Text:

PDF

References


Aguirre, O., Hui, G., Gadow, K.v. and Jiménez, J., 2003. An analysis of spatial forest structure using neighbourhood-based variables. Forest Ecology and Management, 183, 137-145.

Atkinson, P.M., Foody, G.M., Gething, P.W., Mathur, A. and Kelly, C.K., 2007. Investigating spatial structure in specific tree species in ancient semi‐natural woodland using remote sensing and marked point pattern analysis. Ecography, 30(1), 88-104.

Besag, J., 1977. Contribution to the discussion on Dr. Ripley's paper. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 39, 93-195.

Bettinger, P. and Fei, S., 2010. One year's experience with a recreation-grade GPS receiver. Mathematical and Computational Forestry & Natural-Resource Sciences, 2(2), 153-160.

Bettinger, P. and Merry, K., 2012a. Static horizontal positions determined with a consumer-grade GNSS receiver: One assessment of the number of fixes necessary. Croatian Journal of Forest Engineering, 33(1), 149-157.

Bettinger, P. and Merry, K.L., 2011. Global navigation satellite system research in forest management: A summary of horizontal, vertical, static, and dynamic accuracy assessments. LAP Lambert Academic Publishing, Saarbrücken, Germany. 64 p.

Bettinger, P. and Merry, K.L., 2012b. Influence of the juxtaposition of trees on consumer-grade GPS position quality. Mathematical and Computational Forestry & Natural-Resource Sciences, 4(2), 81-91.

Bettinger, P., Merry, K., Bayat, M. and Tomaštík, J. 2019. GNSS use in forestry–A multi-national survey from Iran, Slovakia and southern USA. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 158, 369-383.

Carrer, M., Castagneri, D., Popa, I., Pividori, M. and Lingua, E., 2018. Tree spatial patterns and stand attributes in temperate forests: The importance of plot size, sampling design, and null model. Forest Ecology and Management, 407, 125-134.

Clark, P.J. and Evans, F.C., 1954. Distance to nearest neighbor as a measure of spatial relationships in populations. Ecology, 35(4), 445-453.

Danskin, S.D., Bettinger, P., Jordan, T.R. and Cieszewski, C., 2009. A comparison of GPS performance in a southern hardwood forest: Exploring low-cost solutions for forestry applications. Southern Journal of Applied Forestry, 33(1), 9-16.

Diggle, P.J., 2013. Statistical analysis of spatial and spatio-temporal point patterns. Monographs on Statistics and Applied Probability 128. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.

Dohn, J., Augustine, D.J., Hanan, N.P., Ratnam, J. and Sankaran, M., 2017. Spatial vegetation patterns and neighborhood competition among woody plants in an East African savanna. Ecology, 98(2), 478-488.

Edson, C. and Wing, M.G., 2012. Tree location measurement accuracy with a mapping-grade GPS receiver under forest canopy. Forest Science, 58(6), 567-576.

Fajardo, A., Goodburn, J.M. and Graham, J., 2006. Spatial patterns of regeneration in managed uneven-aged ponderosa pine/Douglas-fir forests of western Montana, USA. Forest Ecology and Management, 223, 255-266.

Fan, Y., Feng, Z., Mannan, A., Khan, T.U., Shen, C. and Saeed, S., 2018. Estimating tree position, diameter at breast height, and tree height in real-time using a mobile phone with RGB-D SLAM. Remote Sensing, 10(11), Article 1845.

Fauzi, M.F., Idris, N.H., Din, A.H.M., Osman, M.J. and Ishak, M.H.I., 2016. Indiginous community tree inventory: Assessment of data quality. The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, 42(4), 307-314.

Fauzi, M., Idris, N., Yahya, M., Din, A., Lau, A. and Ishak, M. 2016. Tropical forest tree positioning accuracy: A comparison of low cost GNSS-enabled devices. International Journal of Geoinformatics, 12(2), 59-66.

Gadow, K.v. and Hui, G.Y., 2002. Characterizing forest spatial structure and diversity. In Sustainable Forestry in Temperate Regions, Björk, L. (ed.). SUFOR, University of Lund, Lund, Sweden, pp. 20-30.

Gadow, K.v., Zhang, C.Y., Wehenkel, C., Pommerening, A., Corral-Rivas, J., Korol, M., Myklush, S., Hui, G.Y., Kiviste, A. and Zhao, X.H., 2012. Forest structure and diversity. In Continuous cover forestry. pp. 29-83. Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.

Garzon‐Lopez, C.X., Jansen, P.A., Bohlman, S.A., Ordonez, A. and Olff, H., 2014. Effects of sampling scale on patterns of habitat association in tropical trees. Journal of Vegetation Science, 25(2), 349-362.

Green, L.Y., Mikhailova, E.A., Post, C.J., Darnault, C.C.J.G., Bridges, W.C.

and Schlautman, M.A., 2016. A cloud-based spatial-temporal inventory for sustainable urban soil management. Urban Ecosystems, 19(2), 811-822.

Hui, G., Li, L., Zhao, Z. and Dang, P., 2007. Comparison of methods in analysis of the tree spatial distribution pattern. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 27(11), 4717-4728.

Hung, I., Unger, D., Kulhavy, D. and Zhang, Y., 2019. Positional precision analysis of orthomosaics derived from drone captured aerial imagery. Drones, 3(2), Article 46.

Illian, J., Penttinen, A., Stoyan, H. and Stoyan, D., 2008. Statistical analysis and modelling of spatial point patterns. John Wiley & Sons Ltd., West Sussex, England.

Khot, L.R., Tang, L., Blackmore, S.B. and Nørremark, M., 2006. Navigational context recognition for an automomous robot in a simulated tree plantation. Transactions of the ASABE, 49(5), 1579-1588.

Kiser, J., 2008. Chapter 1, Surveying. In Part 650, Engineering field handbook. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Natural Resources Conservation Service, Washington, D.C.

Law, R., Illian, J., Burslem, D.F., Gratzer, G., Gunatilleke, C.V.S. and Gunatilleke, I.A.U.N., 2009. Ecological information from spatial patterns of plants: insights from point process theory. Journal of Ecology, 97(4), 616-628.

Lee, T., Bettinger, P., Cieszewski, C.J. and Gutierrez Garzon, A.R., 2020. The applicability of recreation-grade GNSS receiver (GPS watch, Suunto Ambit Peak 3) in a forested and an open area compared to a mapping-grade receiver (Trimble Juno T41). PLoS ONE, 15(4), e0231532.

Lewis, J.S., Rachlow, J.L., Garton, E.O. and Vierling, L.A., 2007. Effects of habitat on GPS collar performance: using data screening to reduce location error. Journal of Applied Ecology, 44(3), 663-671.

Merry, K., and Bettinger, P. 2019. Smartphone GPS accuracy study in an urban environment. PLoS One, 14(7): e0219890.

Moustakas, A., Wiegand, K., Getzin, S., Ward, D., Meyer, K.M., Guenther,

M. and Mueller, K.H., 2008. Spacing patterns of an Acacia tree in the Kalahari over a 61-year period: How clumped becomes regular and vice versa. Acta Oecologica, 33(3), 355-364.

Næsset, E. and Gjevestad, J.G., 2008. Performance of GPS precise point positioning under conifer forest canopies. Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing, 74(5), 661-668.

Perry, G.L., Miller, B.P. and Enright, N.J., 2006. A comparison of methods for the statistical analysis of spatial point patterns in plant ecology. Plant Ecology, 187(1), 59-82.

Pommerening, A., 2002. Approaches to quantifying forest structures. Forestry, 75(3), 305–324.

Pommerening, A., 2008. Analysing and modelling spatial woodland structure. Bangor University, Wales, UK (DSc dissertation), University of Natural Resources and Applied Life Sciences, Vienna, Austria.

Pommerening, A. and Grabarnik, P., 2019. Individual-based methods in forest ecology and management. Springer Nature Switzerland, Cham.

Ransom, M.D., Rhynold, J. and Bettinger, P., 2010. Performance of mapping-grade GPS receivers in southeastern forest conditions. RURALS: Review of Undergraduate Research in Agricultural and Life Sciences, 5(1), Article 2.

Ripley, B., 1981. Spatial statistics. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York.

Seidler, T.G. and Plotkin, J.B., 2006. Seed dispersal and spatial pattern in tropical trees. PLoS Biology, 4(11), e344.

Sigrist, P., Coppin, P. and Hermy, M., 1999. Impact of forest canopy on quality and accuracy of GPS measurements. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 20(18), 3595-3610.

Stoyan, D. and Stoyan, H., 1996. Estimating pair correlation functions of planar cluster processes. Biometrical Journal, 38(3), 259-271.

Tait, R.J., Allen, T.J., Sherkat, N. and Bellett-Travers, M.D., 2009. An electronic tree inventory for arboriculture management. Knowledge-Based Systems, 22(7), 552-556.

Trochta, J., Král, K., Janík, D. and Adam, D., 2013. Arrangement of terrestrial laser scanner positions for area-wide stem mapping of natural forests. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 43(999), 355-363.

Uria-Diez, J. and Pommerening, A., 2017. Crown plasticity in Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) as a strategy of adaptation to competition and environmental factors. Ecological Modelling, 356, 117-126.

Vacchiano, G., Castagneri, D., Meloni, F., Lingua, E. and Motta, R., 2011. Point pattern analysis of crown-to-crown interactions in mountain forests. Procedia Environmental Sciences, 7, 269-274.

Velázquez, E., Martínez, I., Getzin, S., Moloney, K.A. and Wiegand, T., 2016. An evaluation of the state of spatial point pattern analysis in ecology. Ecography, 39(11), 1042-1055.

Weaver, S.A., Ucar, Z., Bettinger, P. and Merry, K., 2015. How a GNSS receiver is held may affect static horizontal position accuracy. PLoS ONE, 10(4), e0124696.

Wiegand, T., He, F. and Hubbell, S.P., 2013. A systematic comparison of summary characteristics for quantifying point patterns in ecology. Ecography, 36(1), 92-103.

Wiegand, T. and Moloney, K.A., 2013. Handbook of spatial point-pattern analysis in ecology. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.

Woodall, C., 2002. Point pattern analysis of FIA data. In Proceedings of the Third Annual Forest Inventory and Analysis Symposium, McRoberts, R.E., Reams, G.A., Van Deusen, P.C. and Moser, J.W., (eds.). U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, North Central Research Station, St. Paul, MN. General Technical Report NC-230. pp. 162-170.

Xu, J., Gu, H., Meng, Q., Cheng, J., Liu, Y., Sheng, J., Deng, J. and Bai, X., 2019. Spatial pattern analysis of Haloxylon ammodendron using UAV imagery-A case study in the Gurbantunggut Desert. International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation, 83, Article 101891.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


   

© 2008 Mathematical and Computational Forestry & Natural-Resource Sciences